• CASES

    Search by

Goldentrust Development Inc. v. Chen

Key Issues:

  1. Goldentrust’s Representation

    • Goldentrust sought leave for its principal, Peng Zhang, to represent it in ongoing litigation.
    • Defendants (Owners) opposed this, citing concerns over Zhang’s conduct and Goldentrust’s failure to comply with court orders.
  2. Case Background

    • Goldentrust registered a $275,620.63 lien on the Owners’ property for construction work.
    • Owners counterclaimed for $1,953,000, alleging overcharging, deficiencies, and misrepresentations about Tarion coverage.
    • Goldentrust’s original lawyer withdrew in May 2024, and the company failed to retain new counsel within the required timeframe.
  3. Court’s Findings

    • Goldentrust did not prove it was financially incapable of hiring a lawyer, relying on an inadequate Canada Revenue Agency tax assessment.
    • Zhang misrepresented Goldentrust’s legal representation in October 2024, falsely claiming to have re-retained the previous lawyer.
    • Goldentrust repeatedly failed to comply with court orders, including delays in paying costs.
    • Zhang demonstrated an inability to properly represent Goldentrust due to his misrepresentations, lack of understanding of legal requirements, and prior misconduct.
  4. Decision:

    • The motion to allow Zhang to represent Goldentrust was denied.
    • Owners were awarded $2,000 in costs for a prior motion.
    • Further cost submissions were ordered, with deadlines set for March 19 and March 24, 2025.
    • Final monetary award was not specified.

Legal Basis:

  • Corporations must be represented by a lawyer (Rule 15.01(2)).
  • Exceptions require financial incapacity and reasonable conduct, neither of which were demonstrated.
  • Misleading the court and violating orders undermine credibility and access to discretionary relief.
Goldentrust Development Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
J. Ren Law Professional Corporation
Law Firm / Organization
Not specified
Lawyer(s)

Peng Zhang

Zhiming Chen
Law Firm / Organization
Sabsay Lawyers
Lawyer(s)

Patrick Colquhoun

Yi Niao Li
Law Firm / Organization
Sabsay Lawyers
Lawyer(s)

Patrick Colquhoun

Equitable Bank
Law Firm / Organization
Not specified
Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
CV-23-709591
Construction law
Not specified/Unspecified
Defendant