Facts: Shawn Metzger was convicted for a home invasion robbery based on DNA found on a cigarette butt in a stolen vehicle and a victim's uncertain testimony about hearing Metzger's name during the crime.
Issue: Whether the convictions based on circumstantial evidence were reasonable.
Ruling: The Supreme Court of Canada found the convictions unreasonable and acquitted Metzger, emphasizing the insufficiency of the DNA evidence and the unreliability of the victim's testimony.
Amount Awarded: Not applicable, as the decision was an acquittal with no compensation awarded.
