Background: The case involved judicial review applications by Pacific Northwest Raptors Ltd. regarding decisions of the Canadian International Trade Tribunal (CITT). The disputes arose from a contract award for aerodrome wildlife control services at Canadian Forces Base Trenton and Detachment Mountain View.

CITT Decisions:

• The CITT found Falcon Environmental Inc.'s complaints valid, recommending that the contract awarded to Northwest Raptors be terminated and given to Falcon.
• In a subsequent decision, the CITT advised re-evaluating Northwest Raptors' bid in light of a third complaint.

Northwest Raptors' Arguments: They challenged the CITT's decisions, claiming breaches of procedural fairness and questioning the reasonableness of the decisions.

Court's Analysis:

• Procedural Fairness: The Court found no breach of procedural fairness in the CITT's handling of the complaints.
• Mandatory Criterion M2: The Court held that the CITT's conclusion on non-compliance with this criterion was reasonable.
• Remedy: The Court supported the CITT's recommendation, dismissing arguments for re-solicitation of the contract.

Decision and Costs:

• Both judicial review applications were dismissed.
• The application in file A-285-20 was dismissed with costs.
• The application in file A-27-21 was dismissed without costs.

Conclusion: The Court affirmed the CITT's decisions, emphasizing the reasonableness of their evaluations and the appropriateness of the remedies recommended. No amount specified for costs.