Search by
Background: The case involves a dispute between the Li Estate (Trustee) as Plaintiff and Clinton Li and Danny Ting Chung Ma as Defendants, regarding a property in Vancouver.
Plaintiff’s Claim: The Trustee alleged that profits from a property sale were used by Ms. Li and Mr. Ma to purchase another property, which was later transferred to Mr. Li. The Trustee claimed a resulting trust against Mr. Li for half interest in this property.
Defendants' Position: The Defendants applied for cancellation of a certificate of pending litigation (CPL) against their property, arguing it hindered planned development. They proposed an undertaking for damages as sufficient security.
Court's Decision:
Costs:
Conclusion: The Court emphasized the strength of the Plaintiff’s claim and the insufficiency of an undertaking as security, requiring a substantial amount to be posted for cancellation of the CPL and awarding costs to the Plaintiff.
Download documents
Plaintiff
Defendant
Court
Supreme Court of British ColumbiaCase Number
S228684Practice Area
Real estateAmount
$ 857,832Winner
PlaintiffTrial Start Date