In this case, a 55-year-old plaintiff sought damages for injuries sustained in a motor vehicle collision. The plaintiff had already been off work for about 16 months due to a work-related hip injury when the collision occurred. The plaintiff claimed that the collision aggravated the hip injury and caused new injuries to his shoulder, neck, back, and psychological well-being, derailing his plans to return to work. The defendant admitted some aggravation of the hip injury but argued that the collision had no effect on the plaintiff's return-to-work plans. The court mostly accepted the defendant's position and rejected the plaintiff's position. The plaintiff was awarded $50,000 in general damages and $3,200 in special damages, but no damages were awarded for past loss of earnings/opportunity, future loss of earning capacity, or future care costs. The plaintiff was entitled to Scale B costs, unless there were undisclosed matters.