• CASES

    Search by

Paramount Resources Ltd v Chubb Insurance Company of Canada

Background:

  • Paramount seeks coverage under its pollution liability insurance policies following a release of pollutants from a low vapour pressure (LVP) pipeline at the Resthaven facility in Alberta.
  • The Resthaven facility was jointly owned by Paramount and ConocoPhillips (BRC) Partnership (Conoco), with Conoco operating the facility.

Incident Details:

  • On April 21, 2016, anomalies in the volume data suggested a leak in the LVP pipeline.
  • Despite pressure tests indicating a significant loss of pressure, Conoco continued to operate the pipeline until June 9, 2016, when a hydrocarbon spill was visually detected.
  • The leak resulted in extensive environmental damage, with the cleanup ordered by the Alberta Energy Regulator (AER).

Legal Issues:

  • Paramount claimed that Conoco detected the leak within the 720-hour window required by the insurance policy for coverage.
  • The insurers denied coverage, arguing the leak was not detected within the specified timeframe.
  • Additional arguments included whether Paramount admitted in prior arbitration that the leak was detected on June 9, 2016, binding it to this position.

Court’s Analysis:

  • Policy Interpretation: The court focused on the interpretation of "detected by any person" within the policy.
  • Evidence of Detection: The court found that volume discrepancies and pressure losses should have led Conoco to shut down the pipeline earlier.
  • Regulatory Compliance: Conoco's actions violated mandatory industry standards for leak detection and response under CSA Standard Z662.

Decision:

  • The court ruled in favor of Paramount, determining that the leak was indeed detected within the 720-hour period based on the available data and regulatory expectations.
  • Paramount was awarded coverage under the insurance policies for the settlement amount with Conoco and other related costs.
  • Specific amount was not provided.

 

Paramount Resources Ltd
Law Firm / Organization
Gall Legge Grant Zwack LLP
Chubb Insurance Company of Canada
Lloyd's Underwriters
Royal and Sun Alliance Insurance Company of Canada
Court of King's Bench of Alberta
1801 08113
Insurance law
Not specified/Unspecified
Plaintiff