• CASES

    Search by

Colbourne Chrysler Dodge Ram Ltd., v. MacDonald et al., v. Colbourne, MacDougall, and Denny

Key Points:

  1. Motion to Stay Proceedings:
    • Defendants sought to stay the court proceedings and resolve the dispute through arbitration under s. 9 of Nova Scotia’s Commercial Arbitration Act.
    • The court granted the stay, directing the parties to proceed with arbitration and allowing the arbitrator to address jurisdictional issues related to personal guarantors.
  2. Background:
    • Defendants owned shares in three car dealership companies sold to 852 NS Ltd. under a Share Purchase Agreement on December 14, 2018.
    • The purchase price was $14.8 million plus working capital, with part secured by a Vendor Take Back (VTB) Note.
    • Colbourne Chrysler alleged fraud, claiming Defendants inflated financial performance data to increase the dealership's sale price.
  3. Arbitration Agreement:
    • The agreement included an arbitration clause (s. 9.01), allowing unresolved matters to be submitted to arbitration.
    • Defendants served a Notice of Arbitration in January 2021, but no formal response followed, leading to this legal action.
  4. Court's Analysis:
    • The court found no undue delay by Defendants and emphasized the strong preference for arbitration under the Act.
    • Claims against personal guarantors were referred to the arbitrator for initial determination of jurisdiction.

Conclusion:

  • The court ordered a stay of proceedings, requiring the parties to pursue arbitration per the Share Purchase Agreement. The arbitrator will determine jurisdictional issues related to personal guarantors and related defenses.
  • The document does not specify the total monetary award.

 

Colbourne Chrysler Dodge Ram Limited
Law Firm / Organization
McInnes Cooper
Lawyer(s)

Tony Mozvik

Jim MacDonald
Chris MacDonald
Mark MacDonald
Ron MacDonald
(The Estate of) Winifred MacDonald
Jim MacDonald Family Trust
Chris MacDonald Family Trust
Mark MacDonald Family Trust
Ron MacDonald Family Trust
MacDonald Auto Holdings Limited
Rodney Colbourne
Law Firm / Organization
Self Represented
Steve MacDougall
Law Firm / Organization
Self Represented
Matt Denny
Law Firm / Organization
Self Represented
Supreme Court of Nova Scotia
Sydney No. 509902
Corporate & commercial law
Not specified/Unspecified
Defendant