Search by
Overview:
The Supreme Court of British Columbia ruled in favor of 0928772 B.C. Ltd. and several other plaintiffs against Lindsay Ross, L.A.C. Ross Law Corporation, My Wee World Enterprises Inc., and others. The case stemmed from financial and investment disputes, with allegations of misconduct during litigation.
Legal Issues:
The primary issue was whether the defendants’ conduct warranted an award of special costs, which are punitive and meant to sanction reprehensible litigation tactics. The plaintiffs argued that Lindsay Ross and Joanne Lynne Ross engaged in misleading testimony, last-minute withdrawal of admissions, and failure to comply with disclosure obligations. The defendants countered that their participation was legitimate and did not justify punitive costs.
Court’s Decision:
Justice Jackson found the defendants' conduct to be "reprehensible," including deliberate attempts to mislead the court, failure to make reasonable admissions, and evasive testimony. The court ruled that the plaintiffs were entitled to special costs against all defendants, jointly and severally.
Award & Costs:
The court ordered special costs for the entire proceeding in favor of the plaintiffs. The exact monetary amount was not specified in the judgment but was subject to assessment. Justice Jackson rejected arguments that the defendants’ financial status should impact the award, emphasizing that special costs are a sanction for misconduct, not a matter of financial capability.
Download documents
Plaintiff
Defendant
Court
Supreme Court of British ColumbiaCase Number
S174615Practice Area
Civil litigationAmount
Not specified/UnspecifiedWinner
PlaintiffTrial Start Date