Search by
Background:
Apex Aluminum Extrusions Ltd. (the plaintiff) supplied materials to KD Sales & Service Limited (the defendant). An invoice for $113,587.30 was issued on November 6, 2020, with payment due within 30 days. Before payment, a third-party fraudster intervened, causing KD Sales & Service to mistakenly wire the funds to the fraudster on January 21, 2021. As a result, Apex Aluminum Extrusions never received payment.
Legal Arguments/Issues:
The plaintiff sought to enforce the contract's interest rate of 2% per month (28.6% annually) on overdue amounts and claimed full indemnification of legal fees. The defendants argued for a lower interest rate under the Court Order Interest Act and sought relief from the contractual interest, asserting that the interest rate acted as a penalty due to the fraud beyond their control.
Judgment:
Costs:
The court awarded the plaintiff full indemnification for reasonable legal fees and disbursements, to be assessed by the registrar if not agreed upon by the parties.
Total Award:
The plaintiff was awarded $113,587.30, contractual pre-judgment interest, and full recovery of legal costs, with the exact amount of costs to be determined.
Download documents
Plaintiff
Defendant
Court
Supreme Court of British ColumbiaCase Number
S238578Practice Area
Corporate & commercial lawAmount
$ 113,587Winner
PlaintiffTrial Start Date