• CASES

    Search by

Jutt Management Inc v Legends Condo Development Corp

Key Issue:
The applicants sought an extension of six weeks to file a notice of appeal, citing Rule 14.8 of the Alberta Rules of Court. The appeal arose from a judgment rendered on July 5, 2024, by Gill J., which involved contractual disputes over condominium purchase agreements.

Legal Findings and Rationale

  1. Extension of Time Request (Cairns Test): The court analyzed the request based on the established criteria in Cairns v Cairns:

    • Bona Fide Intention to Appeal: The applicants demonstrated intent but lacked sufficient promptness.
    • Explanation for Delay: The delay was attributed to incorrect legal advice; however, the court highlighted the applicants' sophistication in business and their ability to seek timely counsel.
    • Prejudice to Respondents: The court found no serious prejudice to the respondents resulting from the delay.
    • Reasonable Chance of Success: The appeal was deemed to lack merit as the trial judge's findings, based on clear evidence and contractual terms, were unlikely to be overturned.
  2. Substantive Issues:

    • The trial court rejected claims of misrepresentation and inducement, finding no credible evidence of agency or actionable promises made by the realtor (Mr. Hahn) that could bind Legends.
    • Alleged deficiencies in the properties were addressed under the contract, and the claims for rescission were ruled baseless.
  3. Conclusion:
    The application for an extension of time to appeal was dismissed as the appeal had no reasonable prospect of success.

Outcome:

The Alberta Court of Appeal denied the extension, concluding that the interests of justice did not warrant prolonging the matter.

The judgment does not specify a monetary award, costs, or damages granted or ordered.

Jutt Management Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
Liberty Law LLP
Lawyer(s)

Zachary Al-Khatib

Somaya Kiana
Law Firm / Organization
Liberty Law LLP
Lawyer(s)

Zachary Al-Khatib

Humza Tahir Jutt
Law Firm / Organization
Liberty Law LLP
Lawyer(s)

Zachary Al-Khatib

Medicine Place Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
Liberty Law LLP
Lawyer(s)

Zachary Al-Khatib

Victor Fei
Law Firm / Organization
Liberty Law LLP
Lawyer(s)

Zachary Al-Khatib

Nauman Jutt
Law Firm / Organization
Liberty Law LLP
Lawyer(s)

Zachary Al-Khatib

Farooq Jutt
Law Firm / Organization
Liberty Law LLP
Lawyer(s)

Zachary Al-Khatib

Legends Condo Development Corporation
Law Firm / Organization
Sharon Roberts Law Group
Court of Appeal of Alberta
2403-0198AC
Civil litigation
Not specified/Unspecified
Respondent