• CASES

    Search by

Benmergui v. YRSCC No. 1510

Key Facts:

  • Benmergui purchased a condominium at 10 Gatineau Drive, Vaughan, Ontario, in July 2024.
  • Since purchasing, she experienced four sewage backups in her unit.
  • The respondent (condo corporation) took steps to address the issue but did not act with sufficient urgency.
  • The applicant sought alternative accommodation costs and compliance orders under sections 117 and 134 of the Condominium Act, 1998.

Legal Issues:

  1. Did the respondent violate the Condominium Act by failing to address the sewage issue?
  2. Is the applicant entitled to financial relief for alternative accommodation?

Court Findings:

  • Violation of Section 117 (Dangerous Conditions): The persistent sewage backups rendered the unit uninhabitable and posed a health hazard.
  • Violation of Section 134 (Failure to Maintain Common Elements): The condo corporation failed to take timely, effective action to remedy the problem.
  • The corporation's lack of urgency was a key factor in the ruling.
  • The applicant had exhausted insurance coverage and could not afford alternative housing.

Court Orders:

  • Alternative Accommodation Costs: The condo corporation must pay for comparable rental accommodation, including first and last month's rent, until the issue is resolved.
  • Legal Costs: The condo corporation must pay the applicant $14,500 in legal costs (partial indemnity basis).
ESTHER BENMERGUI
Law Firm / Organization
Luceo Legal
Lawyer(s)

Breanna Needham

Law Firm / Organization
Pulver on Condos
Lawyer(s)

Shawn Pulver

YORK REGION STANDARD CONDOMINIUM CORPORATION NO. 1510
Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
CV-24-00730433-0000
Real estate
$ 14,500
Applicant